article by Brian Hoober.
Chapter 4 of the book “The God Delusion” is titled “Why There Almost Certainly is No God”. In this chapter Richard Dawkins claims to have demonstrated that “God almost certainly does not exist”. The purpose of this article is to demonstrate using the exact same reasoning that Richard Dawkins “almost certainly does not exist” either !
In the quotes from “The God Delusion” book below we will first quote his reasoning allegedly demonstrating the non-existence of God. Then following we will simply substitute the word “[Dawkins]” where the book used the word “God”, and substitute the alleged creations of Dawkins [ his books] in place of the alleged creations of God [such as the “universe”, etc.]. No other changes will be made.
Here we go . .
Dawkins’ reasoning about the existence of God:
“The argument from improbability, properly deployed, comes close to proving that God does not exist. My name for the statistical demonstration that God almost certainly does not exist is the Ultimate Boeing 747 gambit.” (p. 113, 2006 edition; p. 137, 2008 edition)
“The argument from improbability states that complex things could not have come about by chance.” “The greater the statistical improbability, the less plausible is chance as a solution: that is what improbable means.” (p. 114, 119, 2006 edition; p. 139, 145, 2008 edition)
“God, or any intelligent, decision-taking, calculating agent, would have to be highly improbable in the very same statistical sense as the entities he is supposed to explain . . . any God capable of designing a universe, carefully and foresightfully tuned to lead our evolution, must be a supremely complex and improbable entity who needs an even bigger explanation than the one he is supposed to provide . . .” (p. 147, 2006 edition; p. 176, 2008 edition)
“. . . a God capable of designing a universe, or anything else, would have to be complex and statistically improbable.” (p. 153, 2006 edition; p. 183, 2008 edition)
“I left the conference stimulated and invigorated, and reinforced in my conviction that the argument from improbability – the ‘Ultimate 747’ gambit – is a very serious argument against the existence of God, and one to which I have yet to hear a theologian give a convincing answer . . .” “If the argument of this chapter is accepted, the factual premise of religion – the God Hypothesis – is untenable. God almost certainly does not exist.” (p. 157, 158, 2006 edition; p. 187, 189, 2008 edition)
Exact same reasoning applied to Dawkins’ existence:
“The argument from improbability, properly deployed, comes close to proving that [Dawkins] does not exist. My name for the statistical demonstration that [Dawkins] almost certainly does not exist is the Ultimate Boeing 747 gambit.” (p. 113, 2006 edition; p. 137, 2008 edition)
“The argument from improbability states that complex things could not have come about by chance.” “The greater the statistical improbability, the less plausible is chance as a solution: that is what improbable means.” (p. 114, 119, 2006 edition; p. 139, 145, 2008 edition)
“[Dawkins], or any intelligent, decision-taking, calculating agent, would have to be highly improbable in the very same statistical sense as the entities he is supposed to explain . . . any [Dawkins] capable of designing a [book carefully and foresightfully about evolution], must be a supremely complex and improbable entity who needs an even bigger explanation than the one he is supposed to provide . . .” (p. 147, 2006 edition; p. 176, 2008 edition)
“. . . a [Dawkins] capable of designing a [God Delusion book], or anything else, would have to be complex and statistically improbable.” (p. 153, 2006 edition; p. 183, 2008 edition)
“I left the conference stimulated and invigorated, and reinforced in my conviction that the argument from improbability – the ‘Ultimate 747’ gambit – is a very serious argument against the existence of [Dawkins], and one to which I have yet to hear a theologian give a convincing answer . . .” “If the argument of this chapter is accepted, the factual premise of religion – the God Hypothesis – is untenable. [Dawkins] almost certainly does not exist.” (p. 157, 158, 2006 edition; p. 187, 189, 2008 edition)
The exact same reasoning in “The God Delusion” if applied to Dawkins refutes the existence of Dawkins himself!
How does Dawkins get trapped by his own argument -and thus according to his own reasoning refute the existence of himself?
One of the errors in Dawkins’ reasoning is the switching of the meaning of the word “improbable” within the argument. He defines “improbable” in one way and then changes the meaning to “improbable” in another way in other places. Some things are improbable in one way and not in another. For example a Boeing 747 is improbable by chance, but not improbable as to existence. Dawkins subtly switches the meaning of improbable throughout chapter 4 of his book: Sometimes improbable means “improbable as to existence” other times improbable “means improbable as to coming about by chance”. Richard Dawkins would indeed be very improbable by chance, yet this has no bearing whatsoever on the probability of his existence. Yet his reasoning would link the two and refute his own existence!
Another error in his book [coming soon]
copyright 2014 The Dawkins Delusion.